10 Broken Love Promises That Still Led to Forever
“Broken Love Promises” She broke every promise—but he never stopped loving her. A hauntingly beautiful story about broken love promises, memory, and healing through forgiveness.
Part 1: The Letters Beneath the Floorboards (Broken Love Promises)
(Setting: Cape Whitmore, Oregon — Early Autumn)
The house wasn’t haunted, but it carried echoes.
It creaked in places that shouldn’t creak, sighed with sea wind in its bones, and shuddered at the mention of her name.
When Caleb Wren returned to Cape Whitmore after nearly five years, he didn’t come with flowers or fanfare. He came with a half-written letter in his back pocket and a heart that had forgotten how to hope.
The letter was addressed to the girl who’d promised him ten things.
And kept none.
The old lighthouse cottage hadn’t changed. The faded blue shutters still flapped in the coastal breeze. The porch swing still leaned to the left. And the ghost of Emery Langley lingered everywhere — in the sand-dusted windows, in the smell of peppermint tea, in the crooked photo of the two of them taped to the fridge.
Caleb stood there in the empty kitchen, hand on the dusty counter, remembering the last time he saw her.
She wore yellow that day. Her hair was wind-tangled, her smile apologetic, and her voice almost a whisper as she said:
“Ten promises, Wren. I swear I’ll keep them all.”
He believed her.
God, he believed her.
The First Promise: “I’ll wait for you.”
She didn’t.
When his deployment to Syria stretched past a year, she wrote him a letter. One letter. Then silence.
He wrote her twenty-three.
When he came home early — injured, angry, and lonelier than any war zone ever made him feel — she was gone. Vanished. Left her job, her friends, her life. Left him. No goodbye. No reason.
Only a box with her name scratched off in thick black ink. Inside: the ten promises, each typed on notecards. Torn.
The sea roared outside, crashing against the jagged cliffs like it had a grudge.
Caleb opened the back door, stepped onto the deck, and breathed in the brine. He could almost hear her laugh carried in the wind. Almost.
He wasn’t here for closure.
He was here because something was wrong.
Three Days Earlier:
Mrs. Devlin, the elderly librarian who’d practically raised Emery after her parents died, called him.
“She’s back,” she said. “And not herself. She walks the beach barefoot at dawn, talks to shadows, and… Caleb, she asked if your name still existed.”
“Still existed?” he’d asked, throat tightening.
“She thinks you’re a book she once read.”
Now, standing in the heart of the house they once dreamed of owning, Caleb found the first clue.
A floorboard beneath the old writing desk was slightly raised.
He pried it open with a flathead screwdriver and found a bundle of letters wrapped in yellow ribbon, each one marked with a number:
1 through 10.
The same ten promises.
But now… rewritten.
And on the back of each envelope: a single sentence.
Letter 1: “I didn’t wait for you — because I thought you were dead.”
Caleb stared at the words until his vision blurred.
The wind picked up.
Somewhere in the distance, a woman’s scream echoed across the cliffs.
And just like that—he knew.
Emery was here.
Alive.
And hiding something.
Read More Like Broken Love Promises!
Part 2: The Girl Who Couldn’t Remember Pain (Broken Love Promises)
Cape Whitmore General Hospital — Two Weeks Ago
The sea had brought her back.
Not in a boat. Not even by accident.
She walked out of the waves at dawn, barefoot, drenched, and silent — as if the tide had delivered her on purpose.
When the paramedics found her near Driftwood Point, she had no ID, no bruises, no broken bones. Just a name stitched into the lining of her coat: Emery Langley. And a deep, echoing confusion in her sea-glass eyes.
They asked her where she’d been.
She said, “The in-between.”
Present Day — Caleb
Caleb walked the cliffs that evening, the letters clutched tightly in his hand.
He couldn’t reconcile it.
If Emery was back, why hadn’t she called him? Why hadn’t she reached out? And what did she mean when she told Mrs. Devlin that Caleb Wren sounded like a name from a story?
He followed the sound of windchimes — soft, brittle, oddly familiar.
There she was.
Emery Langley.
Kneeling at the edge of the sea, her hands buried in the sand as if she were searching for something lost long ago.
She turned toward him.
And didn’t flinch.
Didn’t smile.
Didn’t recognize him.
“You look like him,” she said.
Caleb’s voice cracked. “Like who?”
She tilted her head, examining him with eyes he used to know better than his own.
“The boy from the letters. The one who never stopped writing.”
His breath caught.
“You read them?”
“I felt them,” she whispered. “Like ghosts brushing my ribs.”
The Second Promise: “I’ll never forget you.”
She had.
Cape Whitmore Library — Hours Later (Broken Love Promises)
Mrs. Devlin poured chamomile tea and studied Caleb like a professor dissecting a tragedy.
“She’s different,” she murmured. “Gentler. But unmoored. The girl you loved? She’s in there somewhere, but buried. You’ll have to dig.”
Caleb slid the opened letter across the table.
She read silently. Then nodded.
“She thought you were dead. That’s not an excuse… but it is a truth.”
“And the rest?”
“There are more,” Devlin said. “Nine more. Hidden in places only you two would understand.”
The Scavenger Hunt of Memory (Broken Love Promises)
Each letter, rewritten by Emery in the months before she vanished, was a breadcrumb.
A clue.
A confession.
Letter 2: “I forgot you because I forgot myself. Trauma does that.”
Caleb found it behind a paint-splattered canvas in the art studio where she used to volunteer.
Letter 3: “I loved you. Enough to leave when I thought I’d destroy you.”
Taped beneath the church pew where she once made him promise not to become his father.
Letter 4: “I didn’t just break the promise. I broke the girl I was.”
Folded between pages of Wuthering Heights, her favorite book — the one she claimed was more about redemption than revenge.
That Night — Back at the Cottage (Broken Love Promises)
Emery stood in the doorway, dripping from another ocean walk. “Did we ever…?”
“Ever what?”
“Fall in love?”
Caleb didn’t answer right away.
He handed her the stack of four opened letters. “We did. And you left a trail back to it.”
She looked down at the envelopes — hands trembling.
“Why would I do that?”
“Because you believed you’d forget. But some part of you hoped I wouldn’t.”
The wind howled across the sea that night.
And so did Emery.
In her sleep.
Screaming Caleb’s name like a prayer… or a warning.
Part 3: The Map of Broken Love Promises
The Next Morning — Driftwood Point (Broken Love Promises)
The old lighthouse hadn’t functioned in years, but it still guarded the coast like a scarred sentinel. Caleb hadn’t been there since Emery disappeared — it was the last place they’d been together.
Now it stood before him, a skeleton of memories.
Inside the rusted fuse box, he found Letter 5.
“I stood on this cliff the night after your father died. I watched you cry without a sound. That’s when I knew… you were breaking, and I didn’t know how to hold you together. So I did the thing I thought was kindest — I ran. That was broken love promise number five: I promised I’d stay, and I didn’t.”
The paper smelled of salt and age.
So did the regret.
Emery — Later That Afternoon (Broken Love Promises)
She sat on the porch steps, barefoot and quiet, tracing the grain of the wood with her finger.
“I dreamed about you again,” she said without looking up.
Caleb sat beside her. “What happened?”
“You said something I couldn’t hear. Then you disappeared. But the ocean stayed. It always stays.”
He handed her the fifth letter.
Her hands shook when she read it.
“Did I write this?”
“You did. Before the sea took you.”
She turned to him, her voice small. “Is that what happened? Did I go into the water?”
“You did,” he said. “You left your shoes on the jetty and walked in.”
Letter 6: “I was trying to disappear. But even then, I wanted you to find me.”
It was taped to the underside of the piano bench at Ms. Devlin’s — the one where Emery used to play lullabies at 2 a.m. when she couldn’t sleep.
Caleb brought it to her like a relic.
“You’re remembering more,” he said.
She nodded. “But the pain doesn’t come all at once. It’s like… tasting salt on the breeze and not knowing where the wound is.”
Cape Whitmore Community Center — Two Days Later (Broken Love Promises)
He found Letter 7 tucked inside the first-aid kit they used when he broke his wrist during a snowstorm sledding accident.
“You always wanted to save everyone, Caleb. But who saves the boy who gives too much of himself away?”
That night, Emery didn’t cry.
She sang.
A soft, haunting melody in a language only the broken understand.
Letter 8: The Confession (Broken Love Promises)
It was hidden in the old cedar tree — the one they carved their initials into, the one that had grown tall and crooked like their history.
The letter was water-stained and worn.
“There was another reason I left. One I couldn’t write until now. I was pregnant. And I lost the baby.”
Caleb felt the ground tilt beneath him.
He sat down.
Hard.
The Rainstorm (Broken Love Promises)
It came suddenly, battering the coastline like fury unspent.
Emery stood barefoot in it, sobbing, shouting apologies into the sea.
“I broke all ten,” she wept. “Every single broken love promise.”
Caleb didn’t stop her.
Didn’t hush her.
He walked into the rain, wrapped his arms around her, and whispered:
“I never asked you to keep them.”
Letter 9: The Lighthouse Drawer
“If I ever forget who I am, tell me who I was. Tell me I was soft and wild and flawed and brave. Tell me I loved you, even when I couldn’t love myself.”
She remembered this one.
Word for word.
Letter 10: The Final One — Delivered by Devlin
A sealed envelope with their names written in Emery’s handwriting.
Inside:
“If we find our way back to each other…
Let’s make new promises.
Ones we know how to keep.
Ones that start with this:
You. Me. And a love that forgives everything we forgot.”
Caleb’s Answer: (Broken Love Promises)
He didn’t write it in a letter.
He whispered it in her ear.
“Then let’s begin.”
Part 4: When the Heart Remembers What the Mind Cannot (Broken Love Promises)
The Return to Where It All Ended (Broken Love Promises)
The last place they needed to visit was also the one they’d avoided most — the dock behind Caleb’s old house, where Emery had left her shoes before walking into the sea.
The place where silence screamed the loudest.
Caleb stopped a few feet from the end of the weathered wood, the breeze cutting cold through his jacket. Emery stood beside him, still, quiet. Her hand brushed his.
“I remember the cold,” she said, voice trembling. “The water. The weight. But not the reason.”
Caleb didn’t speak.
Instead, he reached into his coat pocket and pulled out the envelope he had kept hidden — the one he never thought she’d be strong enough to read.
Her own final entry.
Letter 11 — Found in Her Sketchbook (Never Sent):
“I loved you too deeply, Caleb. So deeply that when I started to fade, I didn’t want you to witness it. I thought if I disappeared, your memory of me would stay intact. But love doesn’t work like that. And neither does healing.”
Emery sank to the dock, knees folded, the paper pressed to her heart. “I thought I was protecting you.”
“You were breaking me,” he whispered.
“I know.”
A Bonfire of Memory (Broken Love Promises)
That night, they burned the letters.
One by one.
Not out of hatred or regret, but as an offering to the sea, to grief, to the broken love promises that had once haunted every shoreline of their lives.
Emery watched the ashes drift toward the stars.
“Do you think we can love again?” she asked.
Caleb reached for her hand. “Only if we promise to stay when it’s hard.”
“And if I forget again?”
“I’ll keep reminding you.”
Six Months Later — Driftwood Art Show, Portland
Emery’s first public gallery opening.
Each canvas told a story — one of memory, loss, and the promise of return. There were no names on the plaques, just dates and places.
But the final painting, the largest, was titled:
“The Boy Who Kept Every Letter.”
It was of Caleb.
Sitting on the edge of the dock, reading her words again and again.
The New Promises (Broken Love Promises)
They wrote them on paper and nailed them to the lighthouse door:
- I promise to speak, even when it’s easier to stay silent.
- I promise to love you on your worst days.
- I promise to tell the truth — even when it’s ugly.
- I promise to stay.
- I promise to forgive, including myself.
- I promise to keep choosing us.
- I promise to remember — even if I have to relearn it every day.
And the final one, in both their handwriting:
“I promise to let the past be a place we came from — not the place we live.”
Epilogue — One Year Later (Broken Love Promises)
The lighthouse had been repainted.
The dock repaired.
And on a quiet, salty morning, a small ceremony took place with only a handful of friends.
No big vows.
No perfect kiss.
Just Caleb whispering, “You came back,” and Emery saying, “I never left — I just forgot how to stay.”
And that’s how they rewrote the story of broken love promises into something else entirely…
A love that kept going. (Broken Love Promises)
The End of Broken Love Promises
Get more complete book now—exclusively on Gumroad!
Post Comment